Exhibit 1: Rathbun Report
Click here to return to my testimony.
Weekly Tonnage Reports for an AOL Account by Michael Rathbun (originally posted to SPAM-L@PEACH.EASE.LSOFT.COM) Legend: "Pri" = Primary Screen Name "Sec" = Secondary Screen Name "profile" = A profile has been created which can be searched via the AOL Member Directory "PrefMail" = AOL's PreferredMail blocking status "posts to Usenet" = Number of postings placed on USENET newsgroups "UBE count" = Amound of Unsolicited Bulk E-mail (a/k/a UCE) "last post" = date of the last USENET posting (used to gauge time delay between postings and increases in UCE) =================== Date: Fri Mar 14 21:26:49 1997 From: mdr@cyberramp.net (Michael Rathbun) To: SPAM-L@PEACH.EASE.LSOFT.COM Subject: This week's tonnage report for an AOL account In seven days, six hours and 58 minutes my AOL trawler account accumulated a total of 49 pieces of UBE and zero legitimate email. It required a flash session of just under ten minutes to collect them (telnet). For those speculating on the dominant approach to driftnetting the AOL customer base, the following breakdown: profile PrefMail posts to Usenet UBE count last post Pri no ON 11 29 21 Nov 96 Sec no OFF 12 4 13 Dec 96 Sec no OFF 7 0 3 Jan 97 Sec no OFF 3 0 23 Dec 96 Sec yes OFF 17 16 12 Feb 97 Executive summary: the noise level for the primary name is fierce no matter what. I have turned Preferred Mail off for the next week to see what the unfiltered noise level looks like. Out of perverse obsessiveness, I am going to start graphing UBE volume against Usenet activity using the 3 no-profile secondary names, and leave the primary and profiled secondary names alone. If the data look interesting enough, I will put up a summary on a web page. =================== Date: Sat Mar 22 09:27:22 1997 From: mdr@cyberramp.net (Michael Rathbun) To: SPAM-L@PEACH.EASE.LSOFT.COM Subject: This week's tonnage report for an AOL account In seven days, fourteen hours and nine minutes my AOL trawler account accumulated a total of 62 pieces of UBE and zero legitimate email. profile PrefMail posts to Usenet UBE count last post Pri no OFF 11 40 21 Nov 96 Sec no OFF 12 8 13 Dec 96 Sec no OFF 7 4 3 Jan 97 Sec no OFF 3 0 23 Dec 96 Sec yes OFF 17 10 12 Feb 97 Executive summary: turning PreferredMail off on the primary screen name results in a ~45% increase in spammage. =================== Date: Fri Mar 28 22:27:20 1997 From: mdr@cyberramp.net (Michael Rathbun) To: SPAM-L@PEACH.EASE.LSOFT.COM Subject: This week's tonnage report for an AOL account In six days, eleven hours and forty-one minutes my AOL trawler account accumulated a total of 88 pieces of UBE and zero legitimate email. profile PrefMail posts to Usenet UBE count last post Pri no OFF 11 53 21 Nov 96 Sec no OFF 12 11 13 Dec 96 Sec no OFF 7 3 3 Jan 97 Sec no OFF 3 0 23 Dec 96 Sec yes OFF 17 21 12 Feb 97 Executive summary: the trend is not encouraging (up 41% from last week). At this rate of growth, within nine weeks, AOL will require most of the rotating magnetic storage devices on Earth to hold UBE for its customers. This week's bilge discharge contains several copies of the touching "Don't Destroy the Internet!" plea from the public-spirited vendors of Floodgate(tm), wherein they excoriate "stealth mailers" as unlawful to use without payment to an ISP [!]. =================== Date: Fri Apr 04 13:38:20 1997 From: mdr@cyberramp.net (Michael Rathbun) To: SPAM-L@PEACH.EASE.LSOFT.COM Subject: This week's tonnage report for an AOL account In six days, fifteen hours and thirty-six minutes my AOL trawler account accumulated a total of 102 pieces of UBE and one (1!) legitimate email. profile PrefMail posts to Usenet UBE count last post Pri no OFF 11 56 21 Nov 96 Sec no OFF 12 16 13 Dec 96 Sec no OFF 11 11 31 Mar 97 Sec no OFF 3 0 23 Dec 96 Sec yes OFF 17 20 12 Feb 97 Executive summary: most of the increase in the total count this week (102, up from 88) may be attributed to one of the names having been freshly "harvested" after a group of 4 trawler posts on Monday. The graphs will probably not be updated until tomorrow. http://rabendary.tesp.com/UBERate.htm =================== Date: Sat Apr 12 13:31:17 1997 From: mdr@cyberramp.net (Michael Rathbun) To: SPAM-L@PEACH.EASE.LSOFT.COM Subject: This week's tonnage report for an AOL account In seven days, five hours and eleven minutes my AOL trawler account accumulated a total of 63 pieces of UBE and 0.5 legitimate email. profile PrefMail posts to Usenet UBE count last post Pri no OFF 11 34 21 Nov 96 Sec no OFF 12 6 13 Dec 96 Sec no OFF 11 12 31 Mar 97 Sec no OFF 3 0* 23 Dec 96 Sec yes OFF 17 11 12 Feb 97 Executive summary: a precipitous decline from last week's total; perhaps the famed "email brownout" took its toll. I will know more when I update the graphs (real work keeps getting in the way, and I haven't finished the tool to automate the process). * this account received one email: a mailer-daemon notification that a "remove" message to cyberpromo could not be delivered. Taking a CP bolus that had plopped into one account, I did the "reply and type 'remove'" procedure from another account that had never received anything from then. Apparently Mr Wallace knew by occult means that I was inviting him to begin mailing to a mule account, and crashed his remover: >The original message was received at Fri, 4 Apr 1997 16:41:46 -0400 (EDT) >from root@localhost > > ----- The following addresses have delivery notifications ----- >cyberout@pleaseread.com (unrecoverable error) > > ----- Transcript of session follows ----- >cyberout@pleaseread.com... Deferred: Connection timed out with > pleaseread.com. >Message could not be delivered for 3 days >Message will be deleted from queue > > ----- Original message follows ----- > >Return-Path: ********@aol.com >Received: (from root@localhost) > by emout16.mail.aol.com (8.7.6/8.7.3/AOL-2.0.0) > id QAA08099; > Fri, 4 Apr 1997 16:41:46 -0500 (EST) >Date: Fri, 4 Apr 1997 16:41:46 -0500 (EST) >From: ********@aol.com >Message-ID: <970404164143_-1971181182@emout16.mail.aol.com> >To: cyberout@pleaseread.com >cc: ********@****.com >Subject: remove